approaching Raiatea Island from sea, French Polynesia, Society Islands, south pacific
Helen Hatzis
Helen Hatzis
June 24, 2025 ·  6 min read

12 Islands Too Special to Be Tourist Traps

A mindful guide to nature-rich places for the traveller who values preservation over popularity

A beautiful tropical island
Shutterstock

Looking to escape the tourist trail without compromising on experience? These 12 under-the-radar islands deliver everything from remote nature to rich culture and soul-deep relaxation.

Whether you’re after rainforest hikes, coral reef dives, or quiet conversations with locals over fresh-caught seafood, each of these islands offers something unforgettable and still unspoiled. The best part? You can explore responsibly, immersing yourself without overwhelming the destination.

Trade Wi-Fi for Waves on Nikoi Island

Aerial view of a tropical paradise luxury resort on Cousine Island, villas and private beach, Seychelles
Shutterstock

Nikoi Island, just off Indonesia’s coast, might be the closest you’ll get to a modern-day castaway fantasy, minus the stress. There’s no Wi-Fi, no distractions, just 15 hectares of tropical forest, coral reefs, and hand-built villas that blend beautifully into the setting.

Spend your days snorkelling, paddleboarding, or bird-watching, and your evenings soaking in uninterrupted sunsets. The vibe is intentionally off-grid, which makes it ideal for slow travel. It’s also a model for sustainable island living, from locally sourced meals to coral restoration.

Tioman Feels Like Time Travel

A boat leaving Tioman Island, Malaysia
Shutterstock

Tioman Island, off Malaysia’s east coast, skips the tourist circus in favour of something far simpler and richer. Its emerald jungle spills right into the sea, where coral reefs buzz with marine life.

With a few small fishing villages and just enough guesthouses to go around, this is the kind of place where flip-flops replace clocks. Snorkel off the jetty, sip kopi in a wooden warung, and hike to waterfalls through forests echoing with hornbills. Getting there isn’t instant, which helps keep it wonderfully under the radar.

Côn Đảo Balances History with Harmony

Hon Cau beach in Con Dao Island, Vietnam
Shutterstock

Vietnam’s Côn Đảo archipelago holds more than just postcard-worthy beaches. Once a place of exile, these islands now protect endangered sea turtles and dugongs in a carefully preserved marine sanctuary.

Hike through the national park to reach quiet coves, or wander French colonial streets in the main town. It’s remote enough to stay tranquil, but local guesthouses and fresh seafood eateries make it warm and welcoming. The story of this place is layered, and part of the experience is listening as you explore.

Dominica Keeps It Wild on Purpose

Aerial view of Boiling Lake in the Morne Trois Pitons National Park on the island of Dominica
Shutterstock

Dominica isn’t the place for cruise crowds or glittering resorts—and that’s entirely the point. This Caribbean island prioritizes nature, from volcanic peaks to rainforests draped in mist.

Dive into bubbling thermal springs or hike to the surreal Boiling Lake, where the Earth literally steams. It’s also a haven for ethical travel: eco-lodges lead the way, and local guides share deep knowledge of the island’s trails and traditions. The commitment to sustainability is real, which means this place stays as wild as it looks.

Roatán Delivers Depth Beyond the Beach

An aerial view of a beautiful island in Honduras with coral reefs
Shutterstock

Roatán sits on the same barrier reef system that draws divers to Belize and is located off the coast of Honduras, featuring lush jungle interiors, reef-packed waters, and a mix of cultures including Garifuna, Spanish, and English influences.

However, Roatán is no longer under the radar; it has become a major and fast-growing tourist destination, with significant increases in visitor numbers, cruise arrivals, and new tourism infrastructure in recent years

Sure, you can lounge on white-sand beaches, but there’s more to dig into—traditional dance performances, community-run cooking classes, or reef conservation projects you can actually join. It’s a chill mix of Caribbean beauty and meaningful connections.

Haida Gwaii Tells Stories Through Land and Sea

Aerial image of Ninstints, Haida Gwaii, BC, Canada
Shutterstock

Tucked off British Columbia’s coast, Haida Gwaii is a living museum of Indigenous resilience and ecological wonder. Ancient forests, tide pools, and carved totem poles share space with bald eagles and humpbacks.

Visit heritage villages where Haida knowledge is passed down through art, language, and food. Trails through Gwaii Haanas National Park don’t just take you to viewpoints—they carry you through centuries of history. It takes effort to get here, but what you find is worth every kilometre.

Denis Island Is Luxury Rewritten

Beautiful white sand beach in Denis Island, Seychelles
Shutterstock

Denis Island in the Seychelles strips away the cliché version of luxury and replaces it with something more thoughtful. There’s one lodge, no phone signal, and plenty of sea turtles and tropical birds to keep you company.

You’ll find private snorkelling excursions over pristine coral, candlelit dinners with ingredients grown right on the island, and conservation staff who walk you through rewilding efforts. If you’re craving barefoot ease with a serious eco-ethic, Denis delivers an experience that feels both elevated and grounded.

Félicité Pairs Quiet Beauty with Big Impact

A relaxing tropical holiday island in Seychelles
Shutterstock

Until recently, Félicité was a forgotten coconut plantation. Now, this Seychelles island hosts one of the most sustainable luxury resorts in the Indian Ocean, blending dramatic granite cliffs and crystal bays with serious eco-cred.

The villas aren’t just stylish. They’re solar-powered and built to minimise footprint. Hike forest trails where fruit bats flit overhead, or kayak into quiet coves at sunrise. Even the spa uses native botanicals. It’s a high-end experience, yes, but with every detail rooted in stewardship.

Aldabra Is Wild on a Different Level

Corals at the beach of Aldabra Atoll, Seychelles
Shutterstock

Aldabra Atoll doesn’t come with a check-in counter or poolside drinks—but it might be the purest nature trip you’ll ever take. This remote, UNESCO-listed atoll in the Seychelles is home to over 150,000 giant tortoises and dozens of species you won’t find anywhere else.

There are no hotels, just expedition-style liveaboards that operate under strict conservation rules. Days here revolve around lagoon explorations, coral studies, and silent sunsets. It’s not easy to access, but those who do are part of something incredibly rare.

Lipari Offers Italy Without the Fuss

Lipari island in Italy
Shutterstock

Italy’s Aeolian Islands might be gaining attention, but Lipari still keeps things refreshingly low-key. The largest of the chain, it blends rugged volcanic cliffs with a colourful harbour town.

You can soak in natural thermal springs, climb to medieval castles, or sample capers straight from the bush. Archaeological museums, ancient ruins, and slow-paced trattorias bring texture beyond the beach. It’s the kind of island where every walk feels like discovery, without fighting crowds for the view.

Boipeba Brings Back the Basics

Ilha de Boipeba, an island in Bahia, Brazil, near Morro de São Paulo Beach.
Shutterstock

Off Brazil’s coast, Boipeba reminds you how sweet simplicity can be. With no cars and few roads, most visitors explore on foot or by boat. You’ll find untouched beaches backed by palms, and villages where life moves at a human pace.

There’s a strong sense of community here. Locals run eco-pousadas, cook moqueca, and welcome you into slow, joyful routines. Birdwatching, mangrove paddling, and hammock naps all top the to-do list. It’s a place that invites you to exhale and stay awhile.

Raiatea Reconnects You to Culture and Earth

Raiatea Island, French Polynesia, Society Islands, south pacific
Shutterstock

French Polynesia’s Raiatea skips the honeymoon clichés and instead offers depth and cultural resonance. Known as the spiritual birthplace of Polynesia, it’s home to Taputapuātea, a sacred marae and UNESCO site.

Here, you can paddle along the Faaroa River, the only navigable river in the islands. Hike through valleys of wild ginger, or sail to nearby motus where coral gardens shimmer in the shallows. Locals are proud stewards of their land, and you’re encouraged to learn, not just lounge.

Get There Before the Noise Does

Waewaetorea Island in New Zealand
Shutterstock

Whether it’s coral reefs untouched by crowds, forests that hum with ancient stories, or small communities eager to share their world, each spot on this list offers something rare and real.

Travelling responsibly means soaking it all in without taking too much. So go now, tread lightly, and let these places change you in ways big cities never could. Sometimes, the best destinations are the ones that haven’t hit the headlines yet.

Love to island hop? Don’t forget to check out “A First-Timer’s Guide to Caribbean Island-Hopping.”

Every journey leaves a mark, and small choices can make a big difference. Choosing eco-friendly stays, supporting local communities, and being mindful of plastic use help preserve the beauty of the places we visit. Respecting wildlife, conserving resources, and travelling sustainably ensure future generations can experience the same wonders. By treading lightly and embracing responsible travel, we create meaningful connections and lasting memories. Here’s to adventures that inspire and footprints that honour our planet. 

Safe and mindful travels!

Read More